THE UNGLIEST THING on THE MISSISSIPPI
Louisiana's Old State Capitol is a striking example of Neogothic architecture, perched atop a hill in Baton Rouge overlooking the Mississippi River. Designed by architect James Dakin and completed in 1850, the building was established as Louisiana's first permanent state capitol outside of New Orleans, an effort to prevent the state's political power from consolidating in a single city. The building features four towers, offices, a House and Senate chamber, and a grand central staircase crowned by a stunning stained-glass dome. The dome itself is housed within a cast-iron lantern, a later addition to the building. Although designed to evoke the appearance of a resolute stone castle, only two of its facades are actually constructed of stone. The remaining structure consists primarily of brick, accented by cast-iron bands, hood molds, window frames, and crenellation caps. A layer of plaster applied over the brick is scored to imitate the appearance of large stone blocks, further reinforcing the building's masonry aesthetic. For 82 years, the Old State Capitol served as the seat of Louisiana's government before being decommissioned in 1932 following the opening of the New State Capitol.
Famously, Mark Twain called the building "the ugliest thing on the Mississippi" in his 1883 book Life on the Mississippi. He went on to say "It is pathetic enough that a whitewashed castle, with turrets and things – materials all ungenuine within and without, pretending to be what they are not – should ever have been built in this otherwise honorable place... it would have been so easy to let dynamite finish what a charitable fire began". In spite of Mr. Twain's critiques, this "little sham castle" is now a listed National Historic Landmark and a defining feature of the Baton Rouge skyline.
Famously, Mark Twain called the building "the ugliest thing on the Mississippi" in his 1883 book Life on the Mississippi. He went on to say "It is pathetic enough that a whitewashed castle, with turrets and things – materials all ungenuine within and without, pretending to be what they are not – should ever have been built in this otherwise honorable place... it would have been so easy to let dynamite finish what a charitable fire began". In spite of Mr. Twain's critiques, this "little sham castle" is now a listed National Historic Landmark and a defining feature of the Baton Rouge skyline.
PROJECT SCOPE
At nearly 175 years old, the building was beginning to show its age. Cast iron elements throughout the structure were rusting and cracking, paint and plaster were peeling, and masonry cracks were running from window corners. The Architectural Studio was hired to address these issues. Before I joined the firm, the team had previously completed a pilot project on one facade. This four-year effort became the foundation for our approach to the remainder of the building's facades.
In addition to the conditions investigated and resolved during the pilot, we discovered several new issues. At the crenellation caps, for example, many of the severely corroded cast iron pieces were also concealed beneath multiple layers of asbestos-containing mastic. The cast iron lantern on the roof, which channels natural light into the staircase dome, also required significant repairs.
Through this research, we were able to establish the full scope of preservation work needed. In preservation, particularly on nationally registered buildings, quality cannot be compromised. Given the extent of deterioration across the facade, we became concerned that the available funding might not be sufficient to complete the entire building. As a result, we worked with the owner to develop an alternative phased approach. Ultimately, the state was able to fund the entire project at once, but the planning exercise provided valuable insight into how to prioritize and approach large-scale preservation work.
Worker grinds away at old plaster.
Scaffolding over senate chamber. On historic architecture we do not allow scaffolders to mechanically attach scaffolding to the building.
RESEARCH INSIGHTS
As the former state capitol, the building is exceptionally well documented through postcards, photographs, and written accounts. The state has also preserved the architect’s original construction diary, which proved to be an invaluable resource in understanding the issues we encountered. Through these firsthand accounts, we learned that many of the ornamental details, originally designed to be constructed in stone, were quickly replaced with cast iron during construction. We believe this change, coupled with the original designer’s limited understanding of the material, is at the root of many of the problems that have persisted for more than a century. Historic photographs also revealed a history of misguided renovations, leaving behind unusual scars and unique conditions that required careful investigation and resolution.
Seen above is a picture of the capitol after a fire broke out and tore through the building. This took place while Union soldiers were occupying the building. This is unfortunately one of the best photos of the building as it originally existed. We also suspect the heat from this fire may have caused some damage to the cast iron elements which are still present on the modern building.
Retyped excerpt from Daikn's Diary explaining the philosophy behind the castleated design as well as the various costs for different construction methods. We know from later entries that the state opted to take a hybrid approach as Daiken recommended, casting elements like window frames in iron and carving elements like banding out of marble.
In the excerpt, we see the architect was having a great deal of trouble getting the quality of stone needed for the design. After this, he pivoted and had converted many marble features into cast iron. Its our belief that that Daiken was not familiar enough with iron and its material properties (and the implications of replacing marble details with iron) and that this change created problems within the building which we are still fixing to this day...
Historic images and post cards reveal details and explain issues we had to address in this project. Seen here are massive cast iron viewing galleries as well as several decorative iron turrets that were added to the building around the 1880s. These were removed by the 1930s, likely due to instability. Today, the corners where these small turrets existed have been replaced with cast concrete pieces that are now crumbling and are in dire need of replacement.
The building has had several exotic paint jobs over the years including a pink scheme. This card is fascinating because it shows a feature wich is not seen in any other images we've found; an awning over the front window. This discovery allowed us to explain strange hooks that are still affixed to the cast iron frame of the window.
PROJECT WORK
The project primarily focused on cast iron repairs and the complete replastering of the building’s facade. The iron caps, hoodmolds, window frames, and bands all needed to be exposed, laser-cleaned, and recoated to withstand Louisiana’s wet, humid climate. Several sections of cracked iron also required repair. At joints where horizontal bands meet, rust and the natural expansion of iron had damaged the surrounding masonry and broken the embedded clamps that secured these elements to one another. Working with our engineer, we developed an effective replacement detail to address this issue throughout the building.
The existing plaster was also in poor condition and needed to be replaced across the entire facade. In areas where moisture lingered due to localized microclimates, the paint had begun to peel as well. To address this, we specified a through-colored lime plaster that allows moisture to escape more readily and eliminates the need for any future maintenance or repainting.
The drawings for the Old State Capitol required particular care to clearly communicate differences in materials and the plaster’s faux-stone scoring pattern. Starting from scratch, I meticulously measured and photographed all areas accessible on foot before developing a detailed set of elevations. The original scoring pattern is precisely documented in these drawings so it can be accurately replicated during replastering. I'm particularly pleased with how this drawing set turned out and hope its level of detail will prove useful to future preservation teams.
LESSONS FROM THE PROJECT
As with the New State Capitol, it was an absolute honor to work on a building of such historical significance to the people of Louisiana. The Old State Capitol remains a source of pride for Baton Rouge and the state as a whole. Today, it serves as Louisiana’s political history museum and a venue for events, including balls and weddings.
Below are just a few of the things I accomplished while working on this remarkable building:
Below are just a few of the things I accomplished while working on this remarkable building:
•I learned a great deal about the treatment of architectural metals as well as the issues that can be caused by adjoining dissimilar materials, like metal embedded in masonry.
•I worked alongside our preservation specialist to research, investigate, and probe the building in order to create a comprehensive exterior preservation plan.
•I created a detailed set of construction drawings from scratch, documenting existing conditions and architectural details for both construction and reference by future preservation teams.
•Collaborated with firm principals and the building owners to develop a construction phasing plan that balanced project goals with budget constraints